For “SNL,” like all long-running TV shows, it’s all about ratings and relevancy. By Sunday afternoon, there were more than 3 million views of Musk’s monologue
on YouTube and early ratings showed a big win
on the audience front.
For Musk, the apparent goal was to make himself likeable to those who know him only as the Tesla and SpaceX founder who has been criticized for his controversial remarks. And if you watched his monologue
in a vacuum, Musk did come across likeable and funny. He also candidly acknowledged he had Asperger’s syndrome
, an autism spectrum disorder that affects language and communication skills. (Although his claim
that he was the first person with Asperger’s to host was incorrect. Dan Aykroyd, a former “SNL” cast member who hosted the show in 2003, also has the syndrome.
Musk even brought his mother on stage to joke about his childhood. It was a dream for any PR person working to improve Musk’s image. But nowhere did Musk offer any remorse for his particularly reviled statements over the last 13 months.
The most astounding part is that during the show’s monologue, Musk actually had the perfect moment to show he had the strength required to apologize. Musk stated mid-speech “Look, I know I sometimes post or say strange things, but that’s just how my brain works.”
Did he then note it was wrong to undermine the risks posed by Covid or to voice his ridicule about using the correct pronouns
for people in the transgender community — made worse when he defended himself by tweeting:
“I absolutely support trans, but all these pronouns are an esthetic nightmare? Nope. Instead, Musk appeared to make excuses for his remarks: “To anyone I’ve offended, I just wanted to say: I reinvented electric cars and I’m sending people to Mars on a rocket ship.” He then added, “Did you think I was also going to be a chill, normal dude?”
Musk missed another opportunity in a riff on people being judged by the “dumbest things” they’d ever done. Incredibly, he thought his dumbest thing was to smoke weed on a podcast. Overall, he seems to be telling us to accept his past — and any possibly hurtful or irresponsible comments he makes in the future — because he’s a successful executive who helped send people into space. Really? (Ironically, one not-so-smart business move may have been his reference to Dogecoin, the cryptocurrency that he has touted in the past. Its value dropped dramatically
after he jokingly called it a “hustle”
during the show.)
This is not about demanding that “SNL” — or any comedy show — avoid people who will attract media coverage. In fact, in order for “SNL” to remain relevant after 46 years on air, it must court some controversy. Before Musk appeared on the show, I wrote for CNN
that Musk didn’t deserve the “honor” of hosting this show, but I didn’t call for the show to disinvite him.
My hope was that Musk would use the show to acknowledge (even comically) that his irresponsible comments and actions had a real-world negative consequence on people’s lives. For example, it was not just that Musk slammed Covid restrictions last year as “fascist,”
he reopened his Tesla facility in Fremont, California, in defiance of the state’s Covid guidelines last May. More than 400 employees there tested positive for Covid over the next seven months.
In addition, Musk’s comments ridiculing the idea of using the appropriate pronouns for people in the transgender community came at a time that Republicans in state legislatures were gearing up to introduce bills curbing the rights
of transgender people across the country.
The pain caused by these laws has led some parents of transgender teens to move
from GOP-controlled states because of the anti-trans environment these laws are fostering. Musk could easily have used “SNL” to make the apology requested by the Human Rights Campaign
, a leading LGBTQ rights group, back in December.
The bigger issue is that Musk, who boasts nearly 54 million
Twitter followers and a devoted base of fans
, is sending a message to this massive group of people that this type of conduct is acceptable in our society. Appallingly, “SNL” helped him send that very message in the pursuit of ratings and relevance.